The Saudi Arabian government has banned pilgrims from taking photos and videos using any devices for any purpose at Islam’s two holiest mosques.
Makkah and Madinah are religious centers for Muslims. People urge to go to these places for their whole lives. Where the other world has dream destinations in Switzerland and Thailand, the Muslims wish to visit Makkah and Madinah. The Islam originated from there, flourished there, our beloved Prophet (صلى الله عليه وسلم) lived there, and hundreds of religious incidents happened there, thousands of miracles are present in these two holy cities.
According to reports, the ban imposed in Mecca’s Masjid al-Haram, known as the Great Mosque of Mecca, and Medina’s Masjid an-Nabawi, or ‘The Prophet’s Mosque,’ was taken by the Saudi foreign ministry on Nov 12, Turkey’s The Daily Sabah newspaper reported.
Indonesia’s The Jakarta Post reported that the change was communicated by Saudi’s Foreign Ministry through a diplomatic note sent to accredited representatives of foreign countries on Saudi Arabian soil, including Indonesia’s embassy in Riyadh. The embassy received the letter on Nov 15.
Why is this Decision to Ban Photography and Videography Banned?
The Saudi officials explained the reason behind the ban of videography and photography saying,
This step is taken to ensure the respect and dignity of these holy places. Most of the pilgrims waste their time in taking pictures and videos then praying. This not only is disrespectful to the place but also interrupts the prayer of others.
Saudi authorities stated that the measure was imposed to protect and preserve the holy sites, prevent disturbances of worshippers and ensure tranquility while performing acts of worship.
In recent years, many pilgrims to both holy sites have posted pictures on Instagram and Facebook, ranging from posing in front of the Kaaba, to taking selfies on the upper floor of the Grand Mosque to standing under the umbrella-like canopies at Nabawi Mosque.
Some have even posed in groups, carrying banners or flags of their respective countries in the yards of the two mosques. Critics have said such “touristy acts” detracted from the essence of a pilgrimage as they raised questions about whether the pilgrimage was just a trip to take photos.
“In the case of any violation of the ban, security guards have been instructed to confiscate the photos and the camera if needed,” the statement said, adding that the change should be disseminated to every haj and umrah tour operator in their respective countries.
Many Indonesians have expressed their disappointment, saying that photos and videos taken at the mosques were meant as mementos, especially as visiting the sites may be a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity.
Indonesian Nadhira Adiatri remembers taking photos with her family in front of the Kaaba at the Al-Haram Grand Mosque during her umrah (minor haj pilgrame) to Islam’s holiest city of Mecca in Saudi Arabia, five years ago.
“I agree it’s annoying when people take too many photos and selfies, but it’s a pity if we are no longer allowed to immortalise the beauty of the Kaaba or the moving dome in Nabawi Mosque,” the 25-year-old said.
At that time – before smartphone image-sharing apps Snapchat and Instagram became a part of everyday life – security guards at the mosque were already hostile toward people taking photos in the holy compound, she said.
“I only took a few photos using my smartphone camera to capture memorable moments, but I did it quietly to avoid disturbing others and only when the guards were not around,” Nadhira, now a housewife, said on Friday (Nov 25).
Nur Hikmat, 27, who plans to go on umrah next year, said instead of enforcing the ban over the whole compound, Saudi authorities should determine specific areas to ban picture taking.
Another Indonesian who recently returned from Mecca, told the Jakarta Post he had noticed that the ban was already enforced at the Grand Mosque, but that the implementation was not yet strict.
The Indonesian Religious Affairs Ministry’s directorate general of haj and umrah has said it would immediately cooperate with associations of umrah travel operators and the Haj Pilgrimage Counseling Group to disseminate information about the ban to hopeful pilgrims during their pilgrimage preparations, according to a spokesman.
However, Malaysia’s Pilgrims Fund Board (Tabung Haji) said it was not yet informed of the ban and would advise Haj pilgrims once it gets official word from the Saudi Arabian government on the matter.
Tabung Haji chairman Abdul Azeez Abdul Rahim said that if confirmed, Malaysians performing the Haj and umrah would be advised to adhere strictly to the rule.
He added that Tabung Haji would issue an official statement on the matter as soon it was notified by the Saudi Arabian government.